Skip to Content
M7-Rec-08 Compassion, Welfare & Environment Recreation, Arts & Culture CORE Excellence v2.9.7

Creative Expression Reflecting Islamic Values

This criterion assesses the extent to which the organization fosters creative expression (art, music, drama, literature) that aligns with Islamic values through a rigorous, governed framework. It evaluates the provision of platforms for ethically sound, morally uplifting, and spiritually enriching creativity. Key mechanisms include a 'Creative Ethics Rubric' to operationalize values adherence, and a 'Contested Matters Protocol' using a 3-tier classification (Widely-permitted, Contested with conditions, Not permitted) to navigate scholarly differences (ikhtilaf) with inclusivity and adab. The criterion mandates an 'Arts Safeguarding Addendum' covering specific risks (rehearsals, backstage, child performance licensing) and a 'Creative Events Licensing Matrix' for legal compliance (TENs, PRS/PPL, Filmbank). It ensures fair compensation via a commissioning rate card, upholds accessibility through defined checklists and 'Access Riders', and integrates environmental stewardship (khilafah) via 'Green Production Guidelines'. The organization employs a 'Creative Program Theory of Change' to measure impact on wellbeing and identity, ensuring all endeavors reflect the beauty (Ihsan) and perfection (Itqan) of Islamic principles.

Assessment Questions
  1. Does the organization use a 'Creative Ethics Rubric' to score programs on Aqidah, Adab, and Harm Prevention?
  2. Is there a 'Contested Matters Protocol' with a 3-tier classification and Shariah Advisory oversight?
  3. Has an 'Arts Safeguarding Addendum' been implemented for rehearsals, backstage supervision, and child performance licensing?
  4. Is a 'Creative Events Licensing Matrix' used to manage TENs, PPL/PRS, and film rights?
  5. How does the organization ensure online safety (moderation SOP, harms taxonomy)?
  6. Are 'Green Production Guidelines' used to measure and reduce environmental impact?
  7. Does the organization use a 'Commissioning Rate Card' and standard contracts to ensure fair pay and IP rights?
  8. Is accessibility managed via a defined checklist (WCAG 2.2 AA) and 'Access Rider' process?
  9. How is impact measured (Theory of Change, validated tools like WEMWBS)?
  10. Are risk assessments specific to creative events (crowd, AV, sets) conducted?
Evidence Requirements
  • Creative Ethics Rubric logs and Shariah Advisory decision logs.
  • Contested Matters Protocol and Shariah Advisory ToR.
  • Arts Safeguarding Addendum and Child Performance Licence applications.
  • Creative Events Licensing Matrix and copies of licences (TENs, PPL/PRS).
  • Online Moderation SOP and incident logs.
  • Accessibility Checklists and Access Rider examples.
  • Commissioning Rate Card and sample artist contracts.
  • Green Production checklists and waste reports.
  • Impact evaluation reports using standardized tools.
  • Event risk assessments (including fire, crowd, AV).
Scoring Guidelines
LevelRatingDescription
5 5/5 Extensive, impactful programs fully aligned with values and best practice. Creative Ethics Rubric avg ≥4.8/5; 100% safeguarding/licensing compliance; Green Production targets met; ≥90% accessibility compliance; ≥2 flagship programs/year; Mentorship ≥200 hrs/yr; External recognition/awards; Validated impact evidence.
4 4/5 Significant initiatives with clear values commitment. Creative Ethics Rubric avg ≥4.0/5; ≥95% safeguarding/licensing; ≥75% accessibility; Green guidelines implemented; ≥1 flagship program; Mentorship ≥100 hrs/yr; Mixed-method evaluation.
3 3/5 Moderate efforts with documented policy. Creative Ethics Rubric used but scores variable; ≥85% adherence; Basic safeguarding (DSL/DBS) but missing arts-specific addendums; Licensing ad-hoc; Basic accessibility; Some evaluation.
2 2/5 Limited initiatives, minimal alignment. Draft guidelines; frequent compliance gaps (licensing/safeguarding); No formal evaluation or rubric.
1 1/5 Absence of structured programs or presence of prohibited content. No policy; unsafe practices; non-compliant with law or Islamic principles.

Discussion (1)

Administrator 2026-03-07 11:08:15.368615

📋 **Version updated: 1.0.0 → 2.9.7** **Changes:** Updated islamic_references from mizan-297.json

Sign in to post a comment.