Creative Expression Reflecting Islamic Values
This criterion assesses the extent to which the organization fosters creative expression (art, music, drama, literature) that aligns with Islamic values through a rigorous, governed framework. It evaluates the provision of platforms for ethically sound, morally uplifting, and spiritually enriching creativity. Key mechanisms include a 'Creative Ethics Rubric' to operationalize values adherence, and a 'Contested Matters Protocol' using a 3-tier classification (Widely-permitted, Contested with conditions, Not permitted) to navigate scholarly differences (ikhtilaf) with inclusivity and adab. The criterion mandates an 'Arts Safeguarding Addendum' covering specific risks (rehearsals, backstage, child performance licensing) and a 'Creative Events Licensing Matrix' for legal compliance (TENs, PRS/PPL, Filmbank). It ensures fair compensation via a commissioning rate card, upholds accessibility through defined checklists and 'Access Riders', and integrates environmental stewardship (khilafah) via 'Green Production Guidelines'. The organization employs a 'Creative Program Theory of Change' to measure impact on wellbeing and identity, ensuring all endeavors reflect the beauty (Ihsan) and perfection (Itqan) of Islamic principles.
| Metric | Creative Ethics Score |
|---|---|
| Target | ≥4.0 |
| Frequency | Quarterly |
| Method | Average score (1-5) on Creative Ethics Rubric across all programs |
| Unit | Score |
Level 1: Initial/Ad-hoc
Ad-Hoc & Unguided: No formal approach. Activities are sporadic and lack alignment with Islamic values or legal compliance.
Level 2: Developing
Aware & Reactive: Awareness exists, but no formal guidelines or rubrics. Frequent gaps in licensing and safeguarding.
Level 3: Established
Defined & Managed: Policy defined. Creative Ethics Rubric used (avg score variable). Basic safeguarding (DSL) and licensing in place. Contested Matters Protocol exists. ≥85% values adherence.
Level 4: Advanced
Measured & Mentored: Systematically measured impact. Creative Ethics Rubric avg ≥4.0. Arts-specific safeguarding and full Licensing Matrix active. Green guidelines implemented. Mentorship ≥100 hrs/yr.
Level 5: Optimizing
Optimized & Influential: Leader in Islamic creative culture. Rubric avg ≥4.8. 100% compliance. Green targets met. Recognized externally. Validated impact on community wellbeing.
Organisation Types
By Organisation Size
| Size | Applicability | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Micro | exempt | Disproportionate administrative burden; formal advisory boards and complex rubrics are not feasible for volunteer-run groups. |
| Small | optional | Formal Shariah Advisory ToRs are resource-heavy, though basic ethical guidelines can be adopted as a nice-to-have if engaging in arts. |
| Medium | partial | Can implement simplified ethical rubrics and protocols, but a full formal Shariah Advisory Board with appeals processes should be scaled down. |
| Large | full | Has the capacity and structural need for formal advisory boards, detailed rubrics, and arts safeguarding protocols. |
| Major | full | Expected to have comprehensive, multi-tier governance and dedicated advisory structures for all creative outputs. |
Applicable When
- The organization offers or plans to offer arts and cultural programs.
- The organization aims to promote creative expression within the community.
- The organization seeks to integrate Islamic values into its recreational activities.
Not Applicable When
- The organization does not engage in any arts or cultural activities.
- The organization's sole focus is on activities that are strictly prohibited in Islam.
- The organization explicitly promotes values contrary to Islamic teachings.
Related Criteria
Discussion (1)
📋 **Version updated: 1.0.0 → 2.9.7** **Changes:** Updated islamic_references from mizan-297.json
Sign in to post a comment.